California's Genetically Engineered Food Label May Confuse More Than Inform
News > Food
Eliza Barclay
Monday, May 14, 2012 at 12:29 PM
Font size: A | A | A | A |

A new analysis of the labeling initiative, which may go on the ballot in November, shows that it would create a complex and nuanced set of restrictions for food companies on what "natural" food is.

When Californians go to the polls in November, they will very likely have the chance to make California the first state in the nation to require labeling of genetically engineered food. That's according to California Right to Know, which filed a petition to force a statewide vote.

And the group is pretty confident it will succeed. "Polls show that nine out of ten California voters agree that they want labeling," Stacy Melkam, spokeswoman for the group, tells The Salt.

But a new analysis of the labeling initiative shows that if it passes, it would create a complex mandate for food companies that may make it harder — not easier — for consumers to figure out what's really in their food. That's because the initiative also wants to change the definition of a "natural" food.

The word "natural" on a food label is already pretty controversial. It's more of a marketing tool than anything else — seducing consumers into thinking it means healthier, or nearly organic, although it simply means minimally-processed and free from artificial ingredients. The federal government has so far declined to make the term clearer, which has led to many processed foods using the "natural" label.

The activists behind the labeling initiative say they want California consumers to know what they're eating. So they're calling for any processed food or raw agricultural commodity (like corn) that has been or may have been partially or wholly produced with genetic engineering to be labeled as such. And they want to prevent processed foods from using the "natural" label, saying that many are using GE ingredients.

An analysis by Peggy Lemaux, a cooperative extension specialist at the University of California, Berkeley who manages an informational website on biotechnology, found that the new definition of "natural" — as the Right To Know group wants it — would exclude plenty of non-GE and whole foods.

If the proposal passes, a processed food could not be labeled "natural" unless it is a non-GE animal product, certified organic, or an alcoholic beverage.

For example, plain, non-GE rice would not be eligible for the natural label if it had been processed through a mill.

"Basically nothing processed can be 'natural' unless it's a processed organic food," says Lemaux. "It's really limiting, and it is going to make a large segment of the food production people mad."

Activists have been calling for labeling of GE food for many years, but recent petition drives and polls suggest support for labeling is greater than it has ever been. As we reported in March, a coalition calling itself Just Label It commissioned a survey from a national pollster, which found that 91 percent of voters favor labeling.

Some 40 countries around the world now require labels for GM foods. But the U.S. Food and Drug Administration has maintained a firm stance since 2009 that GM labeling is unnecessary. The agency says genetically modified food is essentially the same as other food and poses no safety risk.

Lemaux, who has done extensive reviews of the scientific literature on GE foods, agrees with the FDA.

"This [labeling measure] is not going offer any additional safety to people; it's really not a food safety issue because there's no real evidence this stuff is unsafe," says Lemaux.

What's more she says, the GE and natural labels may scare less savvy consumers away from affordable, healthful foods. And, as we've reported before, Americans really don't understand what genetically engineered food is all about.

"If you're looking to know what's in your food, well there's a lot of stuff in your food, and there's already a lot of stuff on the label," says Lemeaux. "And a lot of people already don't read the label." [Copyright 2012 National Public Radio]



This article is filed in: Food, Science, Home Page Top Stories, News

Also in Food  
Thank The Patron Saint Of Bakers For This Cake Today
The French honor the patron saint of baking with cream-filled cake topped with caramelized sugar.

From Science Fiction To Fact, Robots Are Coming To A Farm Near You
Some dairy farms use high-tech robot milking machines that also clean udders and monitor cow health.

Vermont Beer Makers Bring Back Old-Time Maple Sap Brews
Late season maple sap was used in a potent beer that cooled farm workers in the heat of summer.

Even Your Mother Will Approve Of Vegetable Chips
These baked, seasoned crisps are so tasty and colorful, you might not miss those fried potato chips.

Jetlagged By Your Social Calendar? Better Check Your Waistline
The disconnect between our social calendars and our biological clocks is creating 'social jet lag.'

Comments  
Post a Comment